WAIT! Don’t Leave Before Claiming Your Free Gift...
Struggling to land your first copywriting client - even though you know how to write? This free video shows you the exact method I used to get mine in 24 hours. It’s straight from my $500 course. Just drop your email and I’ll send it over. 👇
WAIT! Don’t Leave Before Claiming Your Free Gift...
Struggling to land your first copywriting client - even though you know how to write? This free video shows you the exact method I used to get mine in 24 hours. It’s straight from my $500 course. Just drop your email and I’ll send it over. 👇
GET PAID LIKE A KING TO WRITE FOR BRANDS YOU LOVE - TODAY!
The "King of Copy" is Giving Away Tips for Becoming a Top Paid Copywriter Right Now
Click the button below to open Jeremy's daily email tips and a FREE video training straight out of his popular $500 course – Overnight Clients
Click the button below to open Jeremy's daily email tips and a FREE video training straight out of his popular $500 course – Overnight Clients
Buyer Behavior Explained: Why People Really Buy (And How You can Profit from it)
Friday, May 23, 2025
Let me hit you with a hard truth most struggling copywriters miss…
You’re not selling copy.
You’re not selling words.
You’re not even selling offers.
You’re selling decisions.
And every decision your prospect makes—whether they click that ad, book a call, or ghost your sales page entirely—is shaped by one thing:
Buyer behavior.
Yet, for some reason, most copywriters barely understand what buyer behavior actually is. They chase templates, headlines, and "secret formulas"... but can’t answer the most important question in marketing:
Why does someone buy?
Without that answer, your copy might sound good... but it won’t sell. You'll keep tweaking buttons and rewriting intros, wondering why nobody’s converting—when the real issue is, you never tapped into the customer’s actual decision-making process.
In this post, we’re going to fix that.
You’re going to learn:
• What buyer behavior actually means (and why it’s way more than just demographics)
• Why understanding it can instantly make your copy more powerful and profitable
• The 3 types of buyer behavior that explain 99% of client decisions
• The psychological factors that influence buying decisions—and how to use them ethically
• The exact step-by-step process buyers follow before pulling the trigger
• And how to use this knowledge to write copy that drives conversions like crazy
This post isn’t theory. It’s a practical deep dive into the buying psychology that makes the difference between a dud and a six-figure sales page.
What Is Buyer Behavior?
Let’s break this down without the fluff.
Buyer behavior is the why behind every “yes” or “no” your prospect gives you.
It’s the thought process, the emotional cocktail, the internal tug-of-war happening in your reader’s head that decides whether they buy... or bounce.
It’s not just about demographics or psychographics. It’s not about age, income, or job title. And it sure as hell isn’t about your product’s “features.”
Buyer behavior is about understanding what’s driving your prospect’s decisions—in the moment—when they’re staring at your sales page or reading your cold email.
Now, this isn’t new.
Claude Hopkins was preaching about testing and observing buyer reactions back in the early 1900s. He knew something most marketers still forget:
If you don’t understand how your customer thinks, feels, hesitates, and decides… you’re guessing.
And guessing kills sales.
Think of it like this: Buyer behavior is the engine behind the entire customer journey. From the second they become aware of a problem to the moment they pull out their wallet, it’s all behavior-driven. All emotional. All influenced by what’s happening between their ears.
So if you’re still writing copy based on “what sounds good” or “what other freelancers are doing,” and you’re not seeing results...
This is likely what’s missing.
Understand buyer behavior, and suddenly your emails get opened, your DMs get replies, and your offers get taken seriously.
Ignore it? And you're stuck tweaking headlines while wondering why nobody’s biting.
Buyer behavior isn’t just a marketing concept. It’s the lens you should be looking through every single time you write.
Why Understanding Buyer Behavior Is Crucial for Your Business
Let me put it plainly:
If you don’t understand buyer behavior, you’re flying blind.
You might have killer writing chops. You might know how to structure a sales page. Maybe you’ve even got a solid offer. But if your copy isn’t built around what actually drives people to buy, none of that matters.
It’s like loading a beautifully polished arrow into a bow with no target in sight.
When you truly understand buyer behavior, everything changes:
• Your messaging stops sounding generic and starts hitting emotional nerves.
• You stop making random tweaks and start making smart, strategic decisions based on what your prospects actually care about.
• You stop trying to “sell” and start guiding your reader through the customer journey in a way that feels natural and frictionless.
Now let’s talk about money.
The fastest path to more conversions isn’t better grammar. It’s not clever headlines. It’s not writing more “persuasive” copy.
It’s knowing how your prospect thinks… what their biggest emotional triggers are… what purchase triggers move them forward… and what hidden fears or client objections are holding them back.
That’s the power of marketing psychology.
It gives you an unfair advantage.
The copywriters who study copywriting psychology and buyer motivation win—plain and simple. Because they’re not writing from the surface. They’re writing from the inside out.
They know what makes buyers tick. And that’s what makes buyers click.
And here’s the kicker:
When you understand buyer behavior, you don’t just sell more... you build real consumer trust. You show prospects that you “get” them. That you’re not just throwing hype their way—you’re solving a problem they feel deep in their gut.
That’s how you create brand perception that sticks.
So before you write your next line of copy, ask yourself this:
Do you actually know why your prospect would say yes?
If the answer’s even a little fuzzy… it’s time to dig deeper into the buying psychology that drives every decision.
The 3 Main Types of Buyer Behavior You Need to Know
Not all buyers are wired the same. If you try to sell to everyone the same way, you’ll sell to no one effectively.
Different people buy for different reasons. And understanding these core behavior types is like having X-ray vision into your prospect’s brain. You’ll know what messaging works, what tone to use, and where to aim your strongest persuasion tactics.
So let’s break down the 3 main types of buyer behavior you’ll run into—and how to tailor your copy for each one.
1. Complex Buyer Behavior (a.k.a. The Research Maniac)
Ever try to sell a premium service to someone who needs to “think about it”? They’re not stalling... they’re analyzing.
This buyer doesn’t make fast decisions. They weigh options, research alternatives, compare prices, read reviews, and probably have a spreadsheet open somewhere. Their decisions are influenced by logic—but also anxiety. They’re afraid of making the wrong choice.
This is where copywriting psychology really comes into play. You need to:
• Reduce risk (social proof, guarantees, track record)
• Answer objections before they ask them
• Show them you understand their world better than they do
• Use proof, specifics, and clarity—no hype
You’re not just selling here... you’re reassuring.
You’re guiding them through the customer journey with hand-holding precision, removing friction every step of the way.
Complex buyers care deeply about decision drivers like ROI, trust, credibility, and the long-term impact of the purchase. Nail those—and they’ll pay premium rates and become loyal clients.
But try to rush them with emotional selling or pressure-based tactics? You’ll lose them fast.
2. Habitual Buyer Behavior (a.k.a. The Creature of Comfort)
This buyer isn’t spending hours researching. They’re not deep in comparison mode. In fact, half the time, they don’t even realize they’re making a decision.
They buy out of habit, convenience, or brand loyalty.
Think about how you grab the same coffee every morning, shop from the same grocery store, or pick the same brand of toothpaste. That’s habitual buyer behavior in action.
And here’s what makes this buyer unique:
They’re not driven by logic or deep analysis... they’re driven by routine and brand perception.
They want to feel safe, comfortable, and certain that what they’re choosing will deliver what they expect—every time.
So how do you speak to this buyer?
• Reinforce familiarity and consistency
• Highlight reliability and predictability in your messaging
• Build consumer trust by showing up consistently across platforms (emails, posts, follow-ups)
• Don’t shake things up too much—they don’t want “new,” they want “known”
This is where marketing psychology meets repetition.
Claude Hopkins nailed it when he said, “People don’t buy from clowns.” If your copy is constantly changing tone, style, or message, habitual buyers won’t stick around.
They want to know what to expect—and feel good about expecting it.
For these folks, the sale isn’t about convincing. It’s about reaffirming. If you can become their go-to resource (the one that always delivers), you’ll win this buyer for the long haul.
3. Variety-Seeking Buyer Behavior (a.k.a. The Emotional Wildcard)
Now this buyer? They're unpredictable. One day they're buying a premium productivity app. The next, they’re impulse-ordering a neon taco holder from Instagram.
They’re driven by curiosity, novelty, and emotional triggers. Logic takes a back seat. What matters most is the feeling they get when they see your offer.
This is where emotional selling and persuasion tactics shine.
These buyers aren’t loyal to a brand—they’re loyal to how something makes them feel in the moment. They want excitement. They want to try something new. And they want to feel like they’re making a fresh, interesting choice.
So how do you hook them?
• Use bold, attention-grabbing angles (not gimmicks—angles)
• Tap into purchase triggers like FOMO, urgency, curiosity, or even rebellion
• Make your copy punchy, unexpected, and emotionally charged
• Use storytelling and visuals that spark imagination or identity shifts
• And don’t forget... novelty is the drug here. If it’s the same ol’ pitch, they’re scrolling past
This buyer isn’t looking for logic—they’re chasing a vibe.
Your job is to craft an experience that lights them up emotionally and moves them to act fast.
Remember, even though their decisions may feel impulsive, it’s not random—it’s still tied to buyer behavior. You just need to know which buttons to push.
And here’s the cool part: Once you’ve got a grip on these 3 buyer types, you can spot them fast. That means you can adapt your copy to match, hit the right decision drivers, and watch your response rates climb.
5 Key Factors That Influence Buyer Behavior
So now that you know the different types of buyers... let’s talk about what actually influences their decisions.
Because here's the deal: nobody makes purchasing decisions in a vacuum. Every prospect you’re writing to is juggling a thousand thoughts, feelings, fears, and desires in their head—even if they don’t realize it.
As a copywriter, your job isn’t to guess what those are. Your job is to know them… and use them.
Here are the biggest decision drivers that shape buyer behavior—and how to use them in your copy:
1. Emotions First, Logic Later
I don’t care how “rational” your prospect thinks they are... every buying decision is emotional at the core.
This is buying psychology 101. People buy because something makes them feel a certain way—then they back it up with logic after the fact.
• “I need this course because it’ll grow my business” (logic)
• Translation: “I want to feel more in control, respected, successful” (emotion)
Want to convert more readers? Get to the heart of what they want to feel—and hit that nerve.
Use emotional triggers like safety, pride, fear of loss, desire for status, belonging, freedom, or relief.
That’s the soul of emotional selling. Not manipulation. Just truth they haven’t put into words yet.
2. Social Proof & Authority
Humans are tribal. If others are doing it—or saying it works—they’re more likely to follow.
Use:
• Testimonials and client results
• Case studies
• Endorsements or name drops
• Specifics over fluff (e.g. “27 clients booked calls” beats “great results”)
This doesn’t just reduce client objections... it boosts consumer trust and reinforces brand perception as credible, proven, and worth betting on.
3. Identity & Self-Image
People buy things that align with how they see themselves—or who they want to become.
If your reader sees themselves as an up-and-coming pro, a high-achiever, or someone who’s “finally ready to take this seriously”… your copy needs to reflect that identity back to them.
Ask yourself: What version of themselves does this offer support? What internal narrative can I affirm?
This is a powerful layer of copywriting psychology. It’s not about your offer. It’s about who they become when they say yes.
4. Past Experiences & Beliefs
Your prospect doesn’t show up to your sales page neutral. They’ve been burned before. They’ve tried things that didn’t work. And they’ve already built mental filters to protect themselves.
You need to acknowledge those beliefs head-on.
Say what they’re thinking. Name the elephant in the room. Then show why this time is different—without sounding defensive or desperate.
This creates consumer trust, diffuses resistance, and primes them for a fresh decision.
5. Environmental & Social Influence
Think: urgency, timing, peer influence, market trends.
Sometimes people buy not because they deeply analyzed the offer, but because:
• Everyone else is jumping in
• They don’t want to miss out (hello, purchase triggers)
• The timing just “feels right”
• They’ve seen your name everywhere and now they’re curious
As Dan Kennedy would say, “It’s not your prospect’s job to remember you. It’s your job to be unforgettable.”
Show up consistently. Stay in front of them. Be the name they associate with answers and results.
You don’t have to use all of these in every piece of copy—but the more you layer in naturally, the more persuasive your message becomes.
It’s not about being slick. It’s about understanding what shapes the entire customer journey—so you can guide them with empathy, clarity, and influence.
The Buyer Decision-Making Process (Step-by-Step)
Here’s where the rubber meets the road.
You can understand every nuance of buyer behavior... but if you don’t know how your prospect actually moves from “maybe” to “hell yes,” your copy will always fall short.
The truth is, every buyer—no matter the industry, offer, or price point—goes through a predictable mental journey before making a decision.
This is your roadmap. Learn it. Use it. And you'll start writing copy that meets them at every stage of the customer journey and moves them forward without resistance.
Let’s break it down.
Step 1: Problem Recognition (aka “Something’s Bugging Me”)
It always starts here.
Something isn’t working. There’s a pain point, frustration, or desire bubbling up. It might be loud (“I need clients NOW”) or subtle (“I feel stuck but I can’t explain why”).
If your copy doesn’t speak directly to this stage... it dies on arrival.
You need to:
• Call out the problem in vivid detail
• Make them feel seen and understood
• Use their language—not yours
• Trigger emotional responses that make them go, “Yes! That’s me.”
This is where emotional triggers do heavy lifting. Pain, frustration, fear of falling behind... it’s all fair game if you do it with empathy and clarity.
Step 2: Information Search (aka “Let Me Poke Around”)
Now that they’ve admitted there’s a problem, they go looking.
They browse posts, ask peers, Google stuff, check competitors. They’re hunting for clarity, options, and answers.
This is your chance to position yourself as the go-to authority.
You do that by:
• Publishing valuable content that educates and builds consumer trust
• Demonstrating you understand the problem better than they do
• Showing up consistently to influence their perception (brand perception builds here)
This is also where copywriting tips come in handy—emails, posts, and lead magnets should all guide them toward you, not just “educate.”
Step 3: Evaluation of Alternatives (aka “Should I Pick You or That Other Guy?”)
Now it’s decision time.
They’re weighing their options. Comparing services. Watching how you communicate. Looking at pricing. And yes... stalking your testimonials and social proof.
Here’s where strong persuasion tactics and strategic sales influence matter.
What you want to do:
• Highlight what makes you different (clear USP)
• Overcome client objections head-on
• Show results, proof, and credibility
• Remind them what’s at stake if they choose wrong
If you’ve built rapport and trust in the earlier stages, this step becomes 10x easier.
Step 4: Purchase Decision (aka “Alright, Let’s Do This”)
They’re ready.
They’ve seen enough. They feel safe. The risk feels lower than the reward.
Now all they need is a final push.
Use purchase triggers like:
• Scarcity (limited spots, deadline)
• Bonuses or fast-action incentives
• Strong CTA with ultra-clear next steps
• Reinforcing the outcome and ROI
But here’s the key: don’t get pushy now. If you’ve done the work up to this point, this step should feel natural, not forced.
Step 5: Post-Purchase Behavior (aka “Did I Make the Right Choice?”)
This is where the magic of long-term client retention happens.
After buying, your prospect is either validating their decision… or regretting it.
This is where you:
• Reaffirm the win (confirmation emails, welcome messages)
• Deliver insanely fast value to squash doubt
• Stay in touch and follow up
• Continue building brand perception and trust
Happy buyers come back. Skeptical buyers disappear.
Understanding this process helps you map your copy strategically across the customer journey—so every line you write has a purpose.
Forget guesswork. This is how you write copy that matches the exact moment your reader’s in—and leads them straight to the sale.
Conclusion
If your copy isn’t converting, the issue probably isn’t your writing—it’s that you’re ignoring buyer behavior.
Start writing to match how people actually think, feel, and decide… and everything changes.
More clicks. More clients. More sales.
Understand the behavior, and you control the outcome. Simple as that.
Want daily copywriting tips to take your career to the next level? Click the yellow "SUBSCRIBE!" button below 👇
GET PAID LIKE A KING TO WRITE FOR BRANDS YOU LOVE - TODAY!
The "King of Copy" is Giving Away Tips for Becoming a Top Paid Copywriter Right Now
Click the button below to open Jeremy's daily email tips and a FREE video training straight out of his popular $500 course – Overnight Clients
Click the button below to open Jeremy's daily email tips and a FREE video training straight out of his popular $500 course – Overnight Clients
20 Portsmouth Avenue, Stratham NH 03885, US | jeremy@jeremymac.com | (207) 517-9957
Jeremy Mac © Copyright 2024. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | Refund | Terms of Service
20 Portsmouth Avenue, Stratham NH 03885, US | jeremy@jeremymac.com | (207) 517-9957
Jeremy Mac © Copyright 2025. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | Refund | Terms of Service